Abstract
This paper proposes a refutation-validated framework for aspect-based sentiment analysis in financial markets, addressing the limitations of correlational studies that cannot distinguish genuine associations from spurious ones. Using X data for the energy sector, we test whether aspect-level sentiment signals show robust, refutation-validated relationships with equity returns. Our pipeline combines net-ratio scoring with z-normalization, OLS with Newey West HAC errors, and refutation tests including placebo, random common cause, subset stability, and bootstrap. Across six energy tickers, only a few associations survive all checks, while renewables show aspect and horizon specific responses. While not establishing causality, the framework provides statistically robust, directionally interpretable signals, with limited sample size (six stocks, one quarter) constraining generalizability and framing this work as a methodological proof of concept.
Abstract (translated)
本文提出了一种用于金融市场方面级情感分析的反驳验证框架,以解决相关性研究无法区分真实关联与虚假关联的局限性。利用能源板块的X数据,我们检验了方面级情感信号是否与股票收益率存在稳健的、经反驳验证的关系。我们的流程结合了净比率评分与z标准化、采用Newey West异方差与自相关一致标准误的OLS回归,以及包括安慰剂检验、随机共同原因检验、子集稳定性检验和自助法在内的反驳测试。在六个能源股票中,仅有少数关联通过了所有检验,而可再生能源板块则表现出特定方面和时段的响应。尽管该框架未确立因果关系,但提供了统计稳健且方向可解释的信号。受限于样本量(六只股票、一个季度),研究结果的普适性有限,因此本文可视为方法概念验证。
URL
https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21473